News

Torture victim's records lost at GuantÃ;¡namo, admits…
This story has mostly positive ratings. 119 votes / 1 sink

Torture victim's records lost at GuantÃ;¡namo, admits…

News – Retired general Michael Dunlavey, who supervised GuantÃ;¡namo for eight months in 2002, tried to locate records on Mohammed al-Qahtani, accused by the US of plotting the 9/11 attacks, but found they had disappeared.

Tags: guantanamo, law, bush, war crimes, 1984

Report

Filter Comments ›
1 - 50 of 60 Comments by 33 members  RSS Feed for comments

1 2 > »

Add Comment
avatar
Reply

Snafu--ya.

avatar
Reply

It seems like whenever a crime is committed, the evidence gets "lost" and *that* crime is never investigated. It's disgusting that anyone could support such an administration filled with criminals, liars and wrongdoing.

avatar
Reply

Hmmm...didn't that happen to Bush's military records, too? They just sort of, uh, disappeared. Funny how these things happen, huh...

avatar
Reply

Actually it's worse. They disappeared and then a different set reappeared on paper and with typing that was inconsistant with the historical period.

avatar
Reply

That was Dan Rather.

avatar
Reply

LOL That was Dan Rather being set up. Bush people knew they were fake because they created them to get Rather fired because the originals were destroyed years before. Bush's dad was the head of the CIA and as the head I don't think for one minute that he would let those papers get in the "wrong" hands.

avatar
Reply

And his wife's auto accident report disappeared, too.

avatar
Reply

WATER BOARDING CAUSES NO SCARS...LETS NO BLOOD, BREAKS NO BONES--ERGO--NO TORTURE

avatar
Reply

Neither does light, or electrodes carefully used, or suspension/bondage. You are an idiot. A direct, intentional, unflattering observation. No need to call me down for it. I know what I'm writing.

avatar
Reply

I see, so there's no such thing a psychological turture.

Let me know when you're ready to give it a try...

avatar
Reply

Don't forget simulated execution.

avatar
Reply

"WATER BOARDING CAUSES NO SCARS...LETS NO BLOOD, BREAKS NO BONES--ERGO--NO TORTURE"

You are a moron.

More than half the US Intelligence and counter-Intelligence officers that go through this kind of torture at the hands of their brothers, knowing full well they will come out of it just fine and are being watched at every moment, end up having severe psychological trauma that needs to be treated. And they know it's 'just a simulation' and that their saviours are right at hand.

You are an embarassment to this country.

avatar
Reply

Not as big as you and your love of Sharia law.

avatar
Reply

You're insane. I don't support Sharia law or any form of theocracy. Not even the one currently in office, or the one responsible for the invasion of a country for no reason.

avatar
Reply

You don't? That wasn't you supporting the call in Britain for the muslims to be allowed to carry out sharia law. I'm pretty sure it was.

avatar
Reply

Frankly, I think a REALLY good definition of torture was given by a member of this Administration (AG Mukasey I believe) "if it happened to me, I would consider it torture".

So not only does this Administration send EVERYONES family members (except their own) into fight this illegal war. But they also use tactics on detainees that THEY wouldn't want to be subjected to and I doubt they would want THEIR family member subjected to.

And before you start spouting off about how these tactics are "getting useful information" and "these people are criminal so they don't count". I would like to point out that...1) there is NO evidence that torture has EVER produced useful information and 2) there have been MORE people RELEASED (because they were innocent) then have been CONVICTED up to this point. Which means (in MY book) that there are MORE people being tortured that have done NOTHING wrong, then those being tortured who DID anything related to 9-11 or since!

avatar
Reply

Which is why it is alternately referred to even within the US military as "the drowning torture."

avatar
Reply

Is that why the US convened war crimes trials against the Japanese after WWII charging them with torture, specifically including water boarding. Because water boarding wasn't torture?

Savage and stupid, a very bad combination.

avatar
Reply

hmm,

Want to volunteer to be water boarded? I mean, if it's no biggie, you should be left unscared and be able to go about your little mindless life, right? You know, a big tough guy like should be able to take it standing on your head.

avatar
Reply

Oh pretty please come to Illinois and introduce yourself. I have a few friends that would love to show you the falsehood of your idiotic comment.

avatar
Reply

Utter disregard for the law seems to be the modus operandi for the military under this administration. Will anyone be held accountable? Doubt it.

avatar
Reply

They have already covered their posteriors when they got congress with McCain's blessings to pass the law that made it "legal" and made the law retroactive to the time they started using torture. Any attempt to bring them to justice would be labeled political by the right wing conservatives.

avatar
Reply

No one is accountable until 1/20/2009. A bold new President has to go after these crooks, prosecute them and ensure such a bunch will never ever take over the government.

avatar
Reply

Of course the problem with that is that McCain sees nothing WRONG with this because these people are NOT protected by the Geneva Convention so torturing them is OK.

avatar
Reply

Oops, maybe they fell into the shredder by accident. I'm sure the 25% that still support Bush would accept that excuse.

avatar
Reply

I'm not surprised. AGAIN.

avatar
Reply

The only thing that would be surprising about Gitmo would be someone who said, "Here are all the records and this is what happens/happened there."

avatar
Reply

LOL! Yeah, THAT would be a surprise. Sad, sad state of affairs where accountability and transparency are the extreme exception.

avatar
Reply

Kind of reminds me of the last days of Enron with their shredding truck.

avatar
Reply

Well, it's such a big place...unprotected borders, anyone can come and go as they like...thousands upon thousands of people pass through with no security, no body searches, no fences and gates, no RFID tags to track their movements...I mean, what do you expect...of course people are going to come in and steal things. And if they can steal them from Guantanamo...well, just think what's happening on our borders...we need those fences now! It's a matter of national security.

avatar
Reply

Are you kidding? You're a fecking idiot.

Even the imprisoned peoples' lawyers can't get in.

avatar
Reply

are you kiddin' me! when did they start letting that happen!?

avatar
Reply

What a big surprise - records lost that would implicate this despicable administration.

avatar
Reply

Lying, Republican, ultra-Conservative, Fundamentalist Christian, Neocon scum.

Maybe it IS time to start torturing some of them so we can get some straight answers.

The Cons obviously aren't going to volunteer the truth any other way...

avatar
Reply

How "holier than thou" and hypocritical of you...

Do as I say not as I do?

avatar
Reply

Well, if waterboarding is 'not torture', they shouldn't have any problem with it, should they?

avatar
Reply

This administration will be keeping the shredders busy the last few months in office. They will be destroying any and all evidence that may be used against them.

avatar
Reply

EVERY administration does this.

avatar
Reply

Yeah right, even those subpoenaed by Congress? What a philosophy...Johnny does it and if he can, so can I.

avatar
Reply

Not a philosophy, a statement. Every administration removes the trash when getting ready to leave. Some administrations have more trash, and of a more toxic nature, than others, but they ALL do it.

avatar
Reply

"EVERY administration does this."

Really? I don't remember any other administrations that have built a torture camp, engage in flying many people to countries that allow torture and start a pre-emptive, imperialist war on other countries. At least not in recent history.

avatar
Reply

i appreciate what you're saying but shredding the paper trail was the point

avatar
Reply

I understand what you're saying, but I think the amount that's being 'shredded' (physically and metaphorically) by this administration during the administration and specifically during investigations far outshines any previous administration's crimes.

avatar
Reply

you right haters are hilarious,,all you need to do is go look at the clinton administration if you want a truly crooked administration. selling nuke secrets,missing fbi files,whitewater,rose law firms billing records, how about those chinese donations, the clinton administration has more people under investigation and charges than any other, not just in recent history but all history,, hey if you dont like bush fine i get that,, but to try and make him worst that bubba and hillary makes me laugh,,,,,bush the greatest american president in modern history,like it or not.

avatar
Reply

eyesclosed,

Really? I didn't know Clinton started Gitmo.

avatar
Reply

no clinton didnt, either did bush,,guantanamo was formed under your other socialist dieties of worship, jfk and lbj. so if you got a problem with gitmo maybe you should go knocking the right people.

avatar
Reply

Ever hear of Teddy Roosevelt? He was president when we leased Guantanamo Bay for a naval base. And he was a Republican, boys and girls, when being a Republican was just being a member of the other party, but still loyal, constitution-supporting, oath keeping Americans.

avatar
Reply

uh he was a bull moose,, and it wasnt until after the cuban missle crisis that gitmo was completely militarized, it was sailor base until then,,,we no longer leased it from that point on, its now a full fledged u.s. military base, thanks to your dieties kennedy and johnson. if you want constitution busters, take a good look at the eschelon program,,you know the super surveillance program set up under the clinton dictatorship,,you know the one based in europe so it doesnt have to follow the u.s. constitution,,,do you remember that one, it wasnt set up to protect anything it was set up to do survellance on u.s. citizens from afar...

avatar
Reply

eyesclosed,

Did you go to school at all? I mean, past the 3rd grade?

It's not that what you say is so ridiculous, it's that you actually believe it.

You know that GED's are offered free these days. Why don't you go and sign up for a couple of classes. It'll do you good.

avatar
Reply

eyesclosed,

Really! How did that happen?

What history book did you get that from?

When did the U.S. go socialist?

Did you get any grade above an F in Civics or History?

1 2 > »

Add Comment

You must log in first to post a comment. Secure Signin

Not a member? Sign-up today!


Who voted on this story?

View all (114) »

Who sunk this story?

Channels
AnchorsArt & DesignAutos
BooksCareers & JobsCelebrities
Do No EvilDo-It-YourselfFamily
FoodGadgets & TechGay & Lesbian
Health & FitnessHumorLove & Personals
MenMoneyMovies
MusicNewsPets
PoliticsPopular VideosReal Estate
ReligionScienceShopping
SportsTelevisionTravel
VideoVideo GamesWomen